Edward
the Elder – Aethelflaed, the “Lady of Mercia” – Aethelstan and Edmund – Eadred
and Dunstan – The End of the Danelaw – Eadwig and Eadgar – Edward the Martyr –
Aethelred the Unready – The Campaigns of Swein Forkbeard of Denmark – The St.
Brice’s Day Massacre – Edmund Ironside – Cnut the Great – The Reign of
Harthacnut – Edward the Confessor and the Rise of Godwine – The Norman Threat
Welsh Warriors - and their severed heads |
Alfred’s son Edward took the throne of
Wessex after the death of his father, and when Aethelred, “Lord of Mercia,”
died shortly thereafter, his wife (and Alfred’s daughter) Aethelflaed took the
reigns of Mercia. Both Edward and Aethelflaed continued their father’s program
of retaking England from the Danes. Aethelflaed was known as “The Lady of
Mercia” rather than as Queen of Mercia, since Mercia still belonged to Wessex.
Her focus was on the re-conquest of northeast Mercia, which was in Danish
control and known as the Five Boroughs. Each borough had its own earl with his
contingent of warriors, and each borough had twelve lawmen who administered
Danish law. Her strategy against the Boroughs was one of sieges and
fort-building, but she also had to march against the Welsh in Gwent who were in
cahoots with the Danes. They rose up to be utterly squashed, and the Gwent king
fled to his Danish allies in the Boroughs. As Aethelred warred against
Danish-occupied Mercia, Edward ousted a Viking incursion from France and
constructed forts along Wessex’s border with Danish-occupied East Anglia. When
his sister Aethelflaed died in 918, Edward annexed Mercia and began conquering
the Danelaw. He moved steadily north, systematically taking town after town. He
took East Anglia, which had been in Danish hands since the death of Guthrum
during Alfred’s day, and when East Anglia fell something shocking happened:
England began submitting to him. The Danish in Northumbria, the Scots far to
the north, and the Britons of Strathclyde bowed to him as “father and lord.” By
924, a year before his death, Wessex dominated England. Alfred’s dream of an
English-ruled Britain had come to pass—but it was a fragile unity soon to
break.
The Battle of Brunanburh |
Edward the Elder died in 925, and his
son Aethelstan took the throne. Though his father had received the submission
of Britain, that submission didn’t last, and Aethelstan’s reign was marked by a
struggle to keep hold of what his father had won. The Scottish king Constantine
rebelled against submission to Wessex and organized a league of Scot, Cumbrian,
Welshmen, and Vikings to oppose the armies of Wessex. In 926 Aethelstan marched
against the North Welsh and forced them to submission, making them pay an
annual tribute, march in his armies, and attend his councils. He treated the
Welsh of Cornwall in the same way and expelled all Welsh folk from Exeter,
which became a purely English town. In 934 he marched north against King
Constantine while his fleet harried the Scottish coast. The Scottish kingdom
was laid waste, but Scotland found a new ally in Northumbria in 937. A
confederacy of Scots, Cumbrians, and Vikings arrayed themselves against
Aethelstan, but he crushed their forces at the Battle of Brunanburh and won
peace for Wessex until his death.
Aethelstan’s brother Edmund succeeded
him at eighteen years of age, and the north once again rose in revolt. The men
of the Five Boroughs allied themselves with Northumbria. The young Edmund was
forced to make peace with the rebels, leaving him a much-depreciated kingdom:
he ruled everything south of Watling Street. Much of his reign would involve
reclaiming that which he had lost at the beginning of his reign: he retook
Cumbria and, in a brilliant move, granted much of Scotland to King Malcolm if
he would be his ally. Malcolm, delighted to expand his borders without having
to fear Wessex’s armies, agreed; thus the Scot and Briton alliance was torn,
and now Malcolm would need Wessex’s help if the Britons ever rose against him.
By the pen rather than the sword Edmund had turned the tables on the Britons.
The reign of Edmund the Magnificent—and that of his successors—was helped by
the brilliance of a priestly monk named Dunstan who had been accused of
sorcery. Dunstan had been part of Aethelstan’s court but had been banished; he
showed his face again during Edmund’s reign, much to the peoples’ dismay. But
Edmund saw something in Dunstan that his brother hadn’t, and he made him not
only Abbot of Glastonbury but also one of his prized counselors. Dunstan likely
played a hand in Edmund’s clever diplomacies with King Malcolm of Scotland, and
Dunstan’s value—and his reputation—would rise under Edmund’s successors.
Edmund was murdered by an exiled thief
during a church service on St. Augustine’s Day, and his brother Eadred took the
throne. Northumbria rose against him, but he secured it by 954. That had been
the last gasp of the Danelaw, and Eadred stifled it. Now the Danelaw would
become enfolded within the English. John Green, in England During the Dark
Ages, notes that
“[when] the English ceased from their onset upon
Roman Britain, Roman Britain had disappeared, and a new people of conquerors
stood alone on the conquered land. The Northern storm [of the Northmen] on the
other hand left land, people, government unchanged. England remained a country
of Englishmen. The conquerors sank into the mass of the conquered, and [Odin]
yielded without a struggle to Christ. The strife between Briton and Englishman
was in fact a strife between men of different races, while the strife between
viking and Englishman was a strife between men whose race was the same… [The]
viking was little more than an Englishman bringing back to England which had
drifted far from its origin the barbaric life of its earliest forefathers.”
In only a few years a Northman of blood
would be made Archbishop of Canterbury, and another would be made Archbishop of
York. Green continues, “[With] Eadred’s reign the long attack which the viking
had directed against western Christendom came, for a while at least, to an end.
On the world which it had assailed its results had been immense. It had utterly
changed the face of the west. The empire of Ecgberht, the empire of Charles the
Great, had been alike dashed to pieces. But break and change as it might,
Christendom had held the vikings at bay. The Scandinavian power which had grown
up on the western seas had disappeared like a dream. In Ireland the viking’s
rule had dwindled to the holding of a few coast towns. In France his
settlements had shrunk to the one settlement of Normandy. In England every
viking was a subject of the English king.” But though the ultimate aims of the
Norse in the west had been foiled, the effects of their ravages were paramount
to the unfolding of European history. John Green captures the essence of
English nationalism as an inadvertent byproduct of the Viking invasions:
In shattering the empire of Charles the Great [the
Viking] had given birth to the nations of modern Europe. In his long strife
with Englishmen he had created an English people. The national union which had
been brought about for a moment by the sword of Ecgberht was a union of sheer
force which broke down at the first blow of the sea-robbers. The black boats of
the vikings were so many wedges that split up the fabric of the roughly-built
realm. But the very agency which destroyed the new England was destined to
bring it back again, and to breathe into it a life that made its union real.
The people who had so long looked on each other as enemies found themselves
fronted by a common foe. They were thrown together by a common danger and the
need of a common defence. Their common faith grew into a national bond as
religion struggled hand in hand with England itself against the heathen of the
north. They recognized a common king as a common struggle changed Alfred and
his sons from mere leaders of West-Saxons into leaders of all Englishmen in
their fight with the stranger. And when the work which Alfred set his house to
do was done, when the yoke of the viking was lifted from the last of his
conquests, Engle and Saxon, Northumbrian and Mercian, spent with the battle for
a common freedom and a common country, knew themselves in the hour of their
deliverance as an English people.
The back end of Eadred’s reign marked a
high watermark for the English people, but after his death things began to go
downhill yet again—but now the danger wasn’t from without but from within. From
Eadred’s death to the Norman Conquest of 1066, English history is marked by a
contest between the king and the nobles. “Who will have the power?” The rise of
feudalism throughout Europe, and in England in particular, meant that nobles
were rising to power with lots of people underneath them. The most powerful
nobles could rival the king, but the English monarch, though forced to deal
with the heavy-hitting nobles, had the support of the Church as the “Lord’s
Anointed” and could curb their power—but they could also curb him. These
political struggles weakened England from the inside, and at times they spread
like a cancer that rendered the king impotent against his foes.
During Eadred’s reign Dunstan rose to
become the see of Canterbury, so that he was the virtual head of the Roman
Church in England. Working behind the scenes in Eadred’s court, Dunstan kept
England unified by allowing the folk of the Daneland (the new designation for
those wide tracts of land where the Danes had previously ruled but who were now
subject to the English king) live by their own peculiar rules and customs.
Dunstan recognized the men of the Daneland as Englishmen, employed them in
royal services, and even elevated them to high positions in both church and
state.
Eadred died in 955, and the throne went
to the child-king Eadwig. Aethelgifu, a woman of high birth, manipulated Eadwig
to the outrage of Eadred’s former counselors. Tensions exploded at Eadwig’s
coronation feast, and Eadwig, sullen by the despoiling of his party, retreated
to his bedchamber. Dunstan, at the bidding of the Witan, drug him back to his
seat. No sooner had the feast ended than was Dunstan declared an outlaw.
Because an outlaw could be killed without repercussion, Dunstan fled across the
sea. Aethelgifu married Eadwig to her daughter, securing her line to the
throne, and she trashed Dunstan’s monasteries. But because the new queen was
Eadwig’s kinswoman, the Church called foul on the marriage, and in 958
Archbishop Odo dissolved the marriage. The Northumbrians and Mercians rose in
revolt, claiming Eadwig’s brother Eadgar as king, and Dunstan was recalled from
Frankia. Eadwig died shortly afterwards, and thus civil war between his
supporters and those of his brother was avoided. Eadgar was only sixteen when
he took the throne, but Dunstan was by his side. It was during Eadgar’s day
that unified England was first called “Engla-land” (or England). Commerce
abounded, justice thrived, and peace reigned—though how much of this was due to
Eadgar and how much to Dunstan’s work behind the scenes is unknown.
Eadgar died in 975 and was succeeded by
Edward (who would become known as “the Martyr”). A host of nobles rose against him, and the
Ealdorman of East Anglia, Aethelwine, wanted to put a young child, Aethelred,
on the throne. The primates of Canterbury and York stood by young Edward, and
Dunstan continued as master of the realm. A religious debate between the
monastics and their opponents threatened the peace of his reign, and that
conflict boiled over when Edward was murdered in 979. Edward’s death opened the
door for Ealdorman Aethelwine’s ambitions, and he got his wish: Aethelred was
put on the throne. Dunstan’s power transferred to Aethelwine and Aethelred’s
mother. Dunstan’s ousting over the realm would have dire consequences, for
Aethelred would face a renewed threat from the north by King Swein of Denmark.
Norway had been the first to become a
monarchy under King Harald Fair-Hair, but Sweden and Denmark followed suit. As
Aethelred neared manhood, the Scandinavian monarchies—no longer
quasi-independent warrior bands under individual chieftains but Scandinavian
armies under Scandinavian kings—set their sights on the land in Britain that
had been ripped from them. But as the threat of a northern invasion loomed,
Aethelred was intent on securing his throne against restless nobles rather than
saving his kingdom from foreign invaders. So determined was he on establishing
his rule that he rejected the advice and wisdom of his counselors, winning
himself the nickname “Aethelred the Redeless,” a play on words that roughly
translates to “Aethelred the Unready.”
Ealdorman Aethelwine died in 991 just
as Viking raiding parties descended on England. Ealdorman Aelfric, who was
supreme in central Wessex after the death of his rival Aethelwine, feared that
Aethelred might want his head to consolidate power and defected to the Danes in
992. In 994 King Swein Forkbeard of Denmark and King Olaf of Norway sailed up
the Thames and anchored off London. Aethelred preferred diplomacy rather than
force and was able to divide the rival Scandinavian kings until troubles back
home drew their fleets from Britain. Aethelred’s fleets then harried Norse
ships in Cumberland and off the Cotentin Peninsula. As he countered the Danes,
Aethelred replaced the ealdormen in his court with court-thegns, who were the
first seeds of the king’s ministers. But the rise of these court-thegns
alienated Aethelred from the support of his nobles, and so the nobles were less
willing to cooperate with Aethelred—and when Swein returned, Aethelred lacked
the support he needed to fight back. Turning again to diplomacy, Aethelred
hoped to make the cost of seizing England too high for the Danes by taking the
Norman Duke’s daughter, Emma, to be his wife. The marriage alliance meant that
any Danes intent on taking England would have to watch their backs against the
rising Norman state on the west coast of Frankia. Aethelred’s alliance may have
helped him in the moment, but it initiated a connection that would cause
heartbreak and bloodshed down the centuries.
Aethelred’s marriage to Emma sparked
panic among the Danish mercenaries Aethelred had hired to garrison his borders.
Hearing of their panic and interpreting it as an uprising, Aethelred ordered
them killed in what’s gone down in history as the St. Brice’s Day Massacre.
Though numbers of the slain are unknown, it was likely in the hundreds. The
massacre, little more than an overreaction on the part of the insecure
Aethelred, only made things worse: receiving news of the slaughter, Swein of
Denmark was moved to action. Disregarding the Norman threat, he sought
vengeance in a retaliatory raid on English soil, and in 1003 his royal forces
landed and cut swathes through southern and eastern England, avenging the
deaths of the Danish mercenaries by slaughtering commoners and torching towns.
Aethelred paid him off, and he returned to Denmark to prepare for a more
permanent invasion.
Before Aethelred could rebuild after
Swein’s raid, a flurry of jarls from Norway descended on England and war spread
through Mercia and East Anglia. Canterbury was sacked in 1012, and its
archbishop was captured and held for ransom. When the money didn’t come, the
archbishop was stoned with bones and ox skulls before being cleaved in the head
with an axe. Aethelred, lacking the support of his nobles, could only watch as
the Northmen closed in on Wessex. His court thegns were vying for power, and
some rose to the rank of ealdormen and declared their feudal independence. The
king was impotent, and in 1013 Swein returned to inaugurate a short but brutal
war. Towns were burned, the countryside was harried, and hundreds were
slaughtered. Oxford and Winchester opened their gates to the Danes, and London
alone resisted. The thegns of Wessex submitted to Swein at Bath, and shortly
thereafter London collapsed. Aethelred fled to Normandy, and in a heartbeat all
of England—Wessex included—had become Danish. All the work of Alfred and his
successors had been undone.
But it wouldn’t last long. King Swein
died in 1014, and Aethelred was recalled by the Witan. He arrived to find the
Danish fleet, now under Swein’s son Cnut, returning north to consolidate the
throne in Denmark, where he ousted his brother and prepared for a fresh
invasion of England. Aethelred’s son, Edmund, revolted against his father and
seized the Danelaw for himself. Before he and his father could come to blows
they were forced to reconcile with the appearance of Cnut in 1015. Mercia and
Wessex bowed before Cnut, and Aethelred met up with Edmund at London to defend
the city against the Danes. Edmund’s prowess in battle was such that he became
known as “Edmund the Ironside.” Aethelred died in April 1016, and Cnut tasted
victory against Edmund at the Battle of Ashingdon in October. Cnut and Edmund
struck a peace treaty by which Edmund was given rule of Wessex while Cnut took
the Danelaw; but when Edmund died in November Cnut annexed Wessex and became,
like his father, master of all England.
Cnut went on a killing spree to
solidify his hold on England: he killed Eadric, the ealdorman of Mercia, who
had given him the crown; he slew Eadwig, the brother of Edmund; and Edmund’s
children sought exile in western Europe and were hunted as far as Hungary. But
once he had a stern grip on his power, Cnut simmered down and ruled both wisely
and fairly. He didn’t change the government, and he ruled justly as if he were
English. He dismissed his troops except for a number of house-carls (or
huscarls) who served as his bodyguard. He relied on good judgment and wise rule
to keep his throne secure. He didn’t treat Danes any differently than
Englishmen; he gave money to the Church and protected pilgrims; and he put
earls in charge of the four major districts (Mercia, Northumbria—now known as
Northumbraland—, Wessex, and East Anglia). The earl of Wessex, Godwine, served
as Cnut’s favored counselor. Cnut’s rule was so benevolent that English ships
and English soldiers didn’t mind fighting for him against rival Scandinavian
monarchies. In 1018 King Malcolm of Scotland won a victory against Earl Eadwine
of Northumbraland and took the northern part of the district; in 1031 Cnut
struck a deal with Malcolm, giving him a tract of land in Northumbraland that
would henceforth be known as Lothian. Scottish kings ruled from Edinburgh, but
theirs was a mixed kingdom of Scots, Welsh, and Englishmen.
When Cnut died in 1035 his rule had
truly been great, but his sons were made of far less quality than their father.
Cnut had chosen his son Harthacnut to succeed him as king over both England and
Denmark, but his absence (he was in Denmark at the time of his father’s death)
enabled his brother Harald Harefoot to take all England minus Godwine’s Essex
(though Godwine would, in time, capitulate). Harthacnut was prepared to use
force against his brother to take what was rightfully his, so England was
poised for a Danish civil war; but Harald died in 1040, and Harthacnut
bloodlessly took England. The bloodlessness of his coronation was countered by
the bloodiness of his reign; he lacked the temper and wisdom of his father.
When Alfred, a brother of Edmund Ironside, returned to England from exile in
Normandy, Harthacnut seized him and his men. Every tenth man of his entourage
was murdered, the rest were sold as slaves, and Alfred’s eyes were gouged out.
Harthacnut then dug up Edmund’s body and cast it into the marshes. An uprising
in Worcester against his huscarls ended with the burning of the town and the
pillaging of its shire. Harthacnut died in 1042, and the English nobles, who
had been content under Cnut the Great but who, under his son, yearned for the
good days of time’s past, called for a revival of Alfred the Great’s line.
Earl Godwine - the future King Harold II |
Earl Godwine, who had tried his best to
keep England unified even under Harthacnut, succumbed to popular feelings.
Aethelred’s one living son, Edward, was called to the throne from Normandy,
where he had spent his youth in exile after Cnut’s seizure of the throne.
History would enthrone Edward the Confessor, the last king of the old English
stock, with a halo of piety. John Green notes that “legends told of his pious
simplicity, his blitheness and gentleness of mood, the holiness that gained him
his name of ‘Confessor’ and enshrined him as a saint in his abbey-church at
Westminster. Gleemen sang in manlier tones of the long peace and glories of his
reign, how warriors and wise counsellors stood round his throne, and Welsh and
Scot and Briton obeyed him. His was the one figure that stood out bright
against the darkness when England lay trodden under foot by Norman conquerors;
and so dear became his memory that liberty and independence itself seemed
incarnate in his name.” But the greatness of Edward’s reign was a mask, for the
real power lie with Godwine of Wessex. Edward was the face of the government
while Godwine was at the helm. Godwine’s son Swein secured an earldom in the
southwest; his son Harold became the earl of East Anglia; his nephew Beorn had
power in central England; and the marriage of his daughter Eadgyth to Edward
secured Godwine’s power. But power struggles and murders among his ambitious
sons weakened his hold.
Edward the Confessor may shine bright
against the dark backdrop of the coming Norman Conquest, but in his day he was
viewed as a stranger. His focus was on his friends and family in Norman exile;
he spoke the Norman language and used a Norman seal for his official documents;
and he put Norman favorites in high church and state posts. Looking back from
1066, the reign of Edward the Confessor could be viewed as the first phase of
the Norman Conquest. Indeed, it is likely that William of Normandy’s claim to
the throne would have been vacuous had Edward not been such a friend to
Normandy. The Norman foreigners filling state and church offices were a check
against Godwine, but when Godwine asserted his power they dared not resist him.
Godwine and Edward came to blows in 1051, and Godwine gathered his forces and
marched on Gloucester, demanding the expulsion of Edward’s Norman entourage.
Because Edward had the support of the earls of Northumbria and Mercia, England
stood poised for civil war. Godwine knew he didn’t stand a chance, so he fled
England. He returned in 1052 with an armed fleet, and Edward yielded. The
Norman officials fled England, and Godwine was restored to his earldom. Shortly
thereafter Godwine died, and his responsibilities passed to his son Harold. For
twelve years Harold stood at the helm of the English government, and under his
guidance peace and justice and commerce boomed. He crushed an uprising of the
Welsh, and when the Earl of Northumbria died, Tostig of the Godwine line took
his place—now the House of Godwine was entrenched throughout England, except
for a small part of Mercia. Edward began to sicken, and his heir, returning
from exile in Hungary, died. Harold bided his time, waiting for Edward to croak
so he could make a bid for the throne. But Normandy had its eyes on England, as
well.
In AD 911 King Charles the Simple of
the West Franks gave a tract of Frankish land to the Vikings under Rollo; that
tract of land became known as Normandy (“the Land of the Northmen”). The Norse
population of Normandy intermingled with the French and became French in
culture and language. England’s connection with Normandy began with the
marriage of Aethelred and Emma, and it had become stronger during the reign of
Edward the Confessor. The Duke of Normandy, known as William the Great (to be
known as William the Conqueror in due time) was a bastard born to a low-born
woman. When his father Robert went on a pilgrimage and never returned, William
became the Duke when he was only a child. Treason and anarchy consumed Normandy,
and in 1047 in a cavalry battle near Caen, William squashed open rebellion. He
ruled Normandy with an iron fist. During Godwine’s exile, as rumor goes,
William traveled to England and received the promise of succession from Edward;
but absent confirmation from the Witenagemot, Edward’s promise was valueless.
When Godwine returned to England,
William considered his English ambitions written off and was forced to deal
with violent barons at home. For six years he fought hard against the barons,
winning significant victories at Mortemer and Varaville, securing his duchy by
1060. Those rebellious barons who hadn’t been slain in battle either rotted in
Norman dungeons or fled to exile. Norman peace led to a boom in wealth,
culture, and learning. William married Matilda, a daughter of the Count of
Flanders, much to the chagrin of the Church. William’s ambitions were revived
when, in a twist of fate and according to legend, Harold Godwine was sailing
the Channel when his fleet was hit by a storm. His ship wrecked on the coast of
Ponthieu, and the count captured him and sold him to William. William treated
him courteously and, seeing his chance, held him for a strange ransom: Harold
had to buy passage back to England by promising and swearing on holy relics
that when Edward the Confessor died, he would support William’s claim to the
English throne. Harold agreed and swore on the relics and returned home.
Edward the Confessor died in 1066, but
Harold had no intentions of abiding by his oath: he took the throne of England.
William decided to sail to England and put in his for the throne based on
Edward’s promise. He didn’t believe Harold’s hasty succession was legitimate,
and he made a personal vow to make him pay for his broken oath. England and
Normandy would come to blows.