In reading over the material, and admitting that they had some very good points (often we integrate norms and moreys in society into our religion and build values from them), it seemed to me that they were saying premarital sex is O.K. just because scripture never tells us not to do it. One thing that did bother me was that they said that premarital sex is a form of loving others, "and isn't that what Jesus called us to do?"
I agree that we often take social do's and don't's and tie them into religion. "Bad words" is an example. Nowhere in scripture are we commanded to avoid using certain words. We are called to avoid corrupt talk and slander, but this is something completely different from using "bad words" in our speech (however, because of social concerns, I avoid using bad language). Yet can we say that premarital sex as wrong is just a tradition? I don't think so. I think premarital sex is wrong because it doesn't fulfill but rather violates Christ's command to love others in several ways:
1) It degrades the worth of the opposite sex. They become mere sex-objects and mere sex-toys, not real human beings with feelings, emotions, consciences and souls.
2) It dishonors future spouses; this flies right in the face of love. Premarital sex often wreaks mischievious havoc in even strong marriages.
4) It dishonors our bodies - do I even need to mention how it might hurt us physically, emotionally, spiritually, mentally? I have many friends, especially at college, who have fallen into this sin, and it weighs on them emotionally, so much that it physically hurts.
5) It draws us to be ruled by our own selfish desires rather than us being led by Christ.
And, mostly:
6) Premarital sex does not have anything to do with Christ's love. Premarital sex, as I understand it, is driven by mere passion and impatience, driven by selfish lust. The "love" in that is a selfish, lustful love. The love that Christ embodies is a selfless, serving, sacrificial, and kind agape love. How can such promiscuous sex be Christ's love when it is inherently selfish? I am dedicated to sacrificing short-term pleasures for my future wife and serving her now by avoiding lust as much as I can. Premarital sex disgregards my future wife and treats her as "just another", not the "one" whom God has for me.
One very good question the Oozer handed to me through his return email: "Should we be anymore concerned with [premarital sex] than with any other sin (such as gluttony, envy, pride, etc.)?" We all know it happens--certain sins are put on a pedestal while others are nearly disregarded (how many Christians will shake their heads at an unwed mother while scarfing down four hundred twinkies?). My reply is thus: "We need a better understanding of sin and we need to just love everybody, regardless of what they've done, what they're doing, or what they're going to do."
As for me, I am thankful I'm a virgin. I hope to keep it that way (and I'm sure that if my future wife were reading my blog, she would be quite the happy camper). These are just some thoughts :). I always claim to be a liberal Christian, but maybe some of my conservatism has shown through here.